Many Faces of TimRSS Icon

Ma’am its royally sucks

It seems to be the time of year for heads of states to relaunch their websites, let's see how our fair Queen managed:

Her Majesties Privacy document

The British Monarchy web site, with the exception of the subscription system, does not store or capture personal information, but merely logs the user's IP address, which is automatically recognised by the web server.

We do not use cookies for collecting user information, and will not collect any information about you except that required for system administration of our web server.

http://www.royal.gov.uk/Contactus/Aboutthissite.aspx

While the above is technically true it is let down by


< script src='../TemplateAssets/GoogleAnalytics1.js' language='javascript' type='text/javascript'>< /script>

Queens SEO

Patrick from blogstorm who also was wandering through the Queens source code noticed the amusing use of meta tags.

< meta name="keyword" content="Queen" />

The single keyword per tag is down to the ASP content management system they are using, actually it seems to do several odd things but at least no SQL errors (unlike the assumed developers site)

Talking of which I did think the web development company (I assume that's the connection) leaving in their URL was a nice touch ;)

< html xmlns="http://www.w3.org/1999/xhtml" xmlns:Abseil="http://www.coraider.co.uk">

Staying on the SEO front, no h1 or 2 tags, and the h3 tags are nicely keyword rich with headings such as "Quick Links" and "Latest Videos" at least most images had an alt tag though no title tags on either images or links.

Royal duplicate content - yes I'm sure you are not surprised that the site itself is an indexed mess, most articles have at least 3 versions (ignoring the welsh and Gaelic language versions) with no order or priority in terms of indexing so some articles the text only version is showing, others the full content. The URL structure is also confused with some pages appearing as

www.royal.gov.uk/output/Page5140.asp

while others are:

www.royal.gov.uk/OutPut/Page6369.asp

Camel casing on a non unix server is not a disaster but if you have a url structure stick with one, but fear not because the new site has done away with these and now use categorised urls...

Only they are not indexed and the old ones, you guessed it 404s

Anything else? I really only spent a few minutes, to be fair the site is no where near as bad as most government websites but still a total fail. When making high profile launches your site will be picked at but sometimes it pays to actually check for the little things.

Update: Even the telegraph is having a dig :) six points for Search engine optimisation for the queen let's hope Queen Elizabeth trusted website team corrects some of their faults.

One final thing and its not SEO or privacy based, why when I look at the site do I think it looks like an old Nuke site?

Quickly Linking?

If you want to link to this post quickly please use: http://tnash.eu/t264

alternativly use one of these services Tiny URL | bit.ly |is.gd

RSS feed | Trackback URI | Add your comment!

4 Comments »

Comment by John
2009-02-24 20:23:59
John avatar

Tim
To be frank – I have not found any govt. site to be SEO web2.0 compatible.
Sooooo…………….

Comment by Tim Nash
2009-02-25 21:15:38

what is web2.0 compatible then?

Comment by Graham from EWD
2009-03-27 17:22:14
Graham avatar

Oh I know the answer to this one. It means you can embed a youtube video and write LOL, OMG and PWNED in the comments box.

And you know this new fangled social networking thing, what is so exciting about going down the pub and uploading a picture of your gurning mates (sorry m8s) to a bleeding myspace page.

Anyone remember newsgroups? Social networking Mark 1.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
 
 
Comment by Melanie from PRO-Webs
2009-03-04 21:36:59
Melanie avatar

I was poking around and clicked this link from the main page http://www.royal.gov.uk/The%20Royal%20Collection%20and%20other%20collections/Overview.aspx with a really stubborn Auth demanding my password and username…. Odd indeed and nice spaces in the file names too lol.

 

Responses to this post:

dont be an idiot, use a real name and all comments are moderated
Name Your name not your website(required)
E-mail (required - never shown publicly)
Website address (URL)
Web site name will be used as link text
Your Comment (smaller size | larger size)
You may use <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong> in your comment.
Spam protection: Sum of 5 + 9 ?
Tim Nash consulting